Online censorship, bias, and BBC Scotland

In November 2011, BBC Scotland took the decision to suspend the comment facility on its political blogs online. This was almost 3 years before the historic vote on Scotland’s independence referendum on the 18th of September 2014. This was an opportunity for the public to engage online on a respected public forum of the national state broadcaster on probably the most important subject in Scotland’s recent history.

Denying this platform effectively gives BBC free reign to publish anything they want, without recourse to correction or challenge. Of course, with the ban being on political blogs, their political correspondants can give personal opinions and can sway public opinion as they see fit. The BBC has a Royal Charter to fairly represent all nations, regions and communities. The BBC is also meant to be impartial, but by disabling comments, it is imposing the unionist based political will and sentiments of Brian Taylor and Derek Fraser on us all, without fair and balanced recourse to counter these viewpoints.

A large porportion of the population rely on the BBC as their main source of information, especially for politics and current affairs. Within this demographic, the BBC are regarded unquestioningly as unbiased, fair and reliable, whereas in actuality, they are openly biased, riven with a one sided view in the political spectrum, and willing to deceive the general populace who are not aware of their blatant pro union and pro Scottish Labour agenda.

Have a look at this link here to see the incestuous BBC Scotland news and politics team that we rely on for balanced news and opinion.

https://lenathehyena.wordpress.com/2014/08/29/oh-what-a-tangled-web-we-weave-when-first-we-practice-to-deceive-bbc-scotland-and-the-labour-party/

It is a bit of an eye opener, isn’t it?

Does Scotland get value for money from the BBC?

The BBC, the National Broadcaster for the UK, works to a set of guiding principles, defining it’s mission and values here

http://www.bbc.co.uk/corporate2/insidethebbc/whoweare/mission_and_values

one of which is “We take pride in delivering quality and value for money.”

The Royal Charter and Agreement also sets out six public purposes for the BBC. See Public purposes. One of those six public purposes is “Representing the UK, it’s nations, regions and  communities”

The question we need to ask is this. Is Scotland as a nation fairly represented by the BBC? Does what we pay them in Licence fees get fairly distributed back to Scotland?

Firstly we need to look at some numbers. TV Licencing stated in that there were 2,197,000 licences in operation in Scotland in December 2011, but were unable to say how much that earned them. What we can ascertain is that there were  in 2012, 25m licences in force UK-wide, earning £3.7bn in revenue for the BBC. So dividing that figure by the number of Scottish licences, we can deduce that earings are about £148 per licence, implying that Scotland’s 2,197,000 licence holders raise £325m a year.

The next thing we need to know is what is BBC Scotland’s budget. The BBC stated that “its Scotland-only budget is £102m, to be cut to £86m by 2017 because of the licence fee freeze.”

Therefore Scotland is a net contributor to the BBC by the tune of some £223m, a figure that will increase to £239m by 2017.

You could say that we get all the rest of the BBC content included in the licence fee, but if you look at the Republic of Ireland, they purchase all the BBC’s content for an annual fee of 25M Euros, and ROI has a similar (slightly smaller) sized population to Scotland, so you could extrapolate that the rest of the BBC’s content is only worth arounf £33m at rates at the time of writing this article.

It still means that Scotland is being short changed by the BBC to the tune of over £190m. A situation that surely needs to be addressed. I’m sure the BBC would not be happy if all Scots decided to pay only 37% of the full licence fee, which is in reality what they are giving back to Scotland